Above, all my aspirin and Tylenol purchases from Amazon since September 2021.
Know that my painkiller meds and regimen of choice are and have always been 3 regular aspirin tablets + 2 Tylenol, every 4-6 hours.
No Motrin, no Advil, or any of the newer analgesics.
Reading the fine print I concluded none are as effective and safe as my combo.
The tens of millions of dollars spent by Big Pharma saying the opposite is true will never convince me.
You've read it here before but one more time never hurts: Old ways are the best ways.

Moin Joe!
ReplyDeleteJust curious, why the acetaminophen preference? I take too much ibuprofen for my urologist's tastes but I find it's the pain reliever with the least amount of question marks.
MfG,
Jake
1. Because it works 2. Because it has a long history of use [in my case since the 1960s] with well-characterized side effects
DeleteThank you, time to try this.
ReplyDeleteI don't know why but "time to try this" amused me...
ReplyDeleteHi Joe, just wondering if you take the dose (3 asperin/2 tylenol) 4 to 6 times a day (IE, 12 or 16 asperin and 8 or 12 Tylenol per day?) I ask because I thought that it was not good to take too much Tylenol per day (max dose 4000 mg per day to reduce chance of liver damage). Would love to hear your thoughts as you are a doctor!
ReplyDeleteDuh on my part- looking at your order history you sometimes buy 100 count bottles 6 months apart. You are certainly not taking 8-12 tylenol a day. Sorry for the question.
DeleteYou raise excellent points and I will try my best to address them all; don't hesitate to ask follow-ups.
ReplyDeleteTylenol 100-count bottle purchase intervals in months since September 2021:
8/5/7/7/11/9/4/5
You wrote, "... looking at your order history you sometimes buy 100-count bottles 6 months apart. You are certainly not taking 8-12 Tylenol a day."
1. My order history doesn't reflect my Tylenol intake for a couple reasons:
a. I have three locations for Tylenol: my kitchen cabinet, the bathroom nearest my bedroom, and my car.
I need to keep all 3 stocked with unexpired Tylenol.
b. Tylenol bottle expiration dates are typically around 18-24 months from purchase date. Thus, my purchase history reflects not only my Tylenol intake but also tossing out expired drugs and buying fresh ones, which I distribute to all 3 locations noted above. The most recent purchase — February 15, 2026 — expires September 2027.
When I need pain relief I do indeed take 3 regular aspirin + 2 Extra-Strength Tylenol, around every 4-6 hours as I wrote in my post.
Let's say I wake up at 8 am with a terrible headache. I will take these drugs at 8 am/1pm/6pm/11pm: so up to 8 Tylenol/day.
That's my upper limit, never more because of the longstanding association of liver toxicity with Tylenol overuse.
An aside: back when I was an anesthesiologist at the University of Viriginia Medical School, a surgical intern attempted suicide by Tylenol overdose in 1983. She succeeded, but the course of her decline was terrible.
Thank you for your reply! I understand now. Re live toxicity: I can imagine this is not a good way to die. I am sorry to hear that she died that way.
DeleteAll the best to you, and I forgot to say I enjoyed many years of your previous BOJ blog- I never got all the way back to the beginning. I am glad you are still writing (and giving me something to read!)